Logan Lewis's morning drive usually seats one guest across the mic. This time it sat four. For a long-awaited Guys on Tap crossover, Logan welcomed his former Guys on Tap co-hosts Corey, Matthew, and Jordan, plus his cousin and Binge Boys throwback partner Tanner, into the new Your Morning Drive home base at 216 Coworking in downtown Cartersville. It had been, by Logan's own count, two years and nine months since Guys on Tap last recorded, and the guys picked up exactly where they left off: five voices talking over each other about everything from Pokemon drafts to pocket-knife etiquette. What follows is less an interview than a live transcript of a friend group's chat thread, brought to life with cans of Good Days in hand.
A Reunion Two Years, Nine Months in the Making
The math got debated almost immediately — was it really nine months, or closer to two years and nine months since Guys on Tap went on hiatus? Once someone did the arithmetic (August 2023), the guys realized their break tracked almost exactly with a wave of newborns in the friend group, Matthew's kid first, then everyone else following what they called 'the precedent.' Before diving into topics, each guy introduced himself for anyone tuning in cold: Corey ('the one with the longest podcast record'), Jordan, Matthew, and Tanner, the cousin who famously subbed in for one Guys on Tap episode back on Juneteenth 2022, a day that included a 5 a.m. gym session, 18 holes at Dogwood, and a recording he barely remembers.
Golf, Rain, and Cobblestone's Uncertain Future
Golf talk ran through most of the middle of the episode, kicked off by a Masters memory — Logan and Corey getting caught in a light drizzle at Augusta and Logan throwing a mini fit about a four-minute rain delay ruining his day. That spiraled into dueling driver stories: Logan bragging about crushing one off the first tee at Cobblestone after sneaking into an unbooked tee time, and the group trading theories about Cobblestone's rumored greens renovation — someone heard 2028, nobody could confirm it — while debating whether temporary greens would actually make the course better or worse. Scores got roasted too. A round of 100 got compared unfavorably to Woodland, 'where everybody shoots in the 70s,' prompting Jordan's blunt verdict: 'You should call me daddy now if I shot that much better than you.'
Softball Bats, Broken Backs, and the Pull of KB's
Softball got its own extended runtime, complete with a full oral history of the group's cracked bat — a warranty-abused 'OG Flipper' that Jordan wrangled a free replacement for during COVID, one that half the team allegedly hit with afterward. There was a story about someone parking a golf cart on the path and getting it stuck, blamed squarely on Matthew, and a claim that a teammate once threw up twice during nine holes of golf and finished the round anyway. Everyone agreed on one rule: nothing short of a deathbed keeps them from softball, golf, or basketball — rain or shine. By the second half of the episode, KB's, the crew's regular postgame bar, kept surfacing as the night's real destination, complete with a running bit about the same song — the national anthem — always hitting the jukebox whenever they walk in.
The Spider-Man Debate and the Great Harry Potter Draft
No crossover episode would be complete without a superhero argument, and this one delivered. Sparked by a rewatch of the No Way Home Spider-Man reveal, the table mostly settled on Tom Holland as the 'good mix' between Tobey Maguire, who 'paved the way,' and Andrew Garfield, 'a dope Spider-Man' who's 'aged well.' From there the conversation pivoted into an impromptu Harry Potter power ranking, with Goblet of Fire, Chamber of Secrets, and both Deathly Hallows parts all pulling votes, plus a side debate over whether Order of the Phoenix actually holds up. The group landed on a shared truth: Snape is the goat of the entire series, and losing him still stings. One guy in the room even admitted he'd never seen a single Harry Potter movie until randomly walking into Deathly Hallows Part 2 and mistaking it for pure action spectacle.
Top Three Movie Theater Memories
Past the halfway mark, the guys turned the mics into a rapid-fire draft of their best-ever theater experiences. Endgame and Infinity War got disqualified as 'too obvious' before the round even started, leaving room for Oppenheimer (including the infamous story of a guy ripping a fart during the silent bomb-test scene), Sinners, F1, the Stranger Things finale shown in theaters, Rogue One (seen seven times by one member), and the Force Awakens opening crawl. Older picks got their due too — Jurassic Park in '94, The Dark Knight, Wolf of Wall Street, and a heartfelt shoutout to The Whale for the gut-punch Brendan Fraser delivered. It was a genuine time capsule of a friend group's shared moviegoing history, swinging from blockbusters to horror-movie sneak-outs, including The Conjuring, watched against a priest's actual Sunday-mass warning not to see it.
Listen to the Full Conversation
From a standing-versus-sitting bathroom debate to an AI-generated controversial-topics list that somehow wound up on the Epstein files and 'He is risen' Easter posts, this episode is proof that four mics and one long-overdue reunion can produce something genuinely unhinged in the best way. Catch the full, chaotic ride with the Guys on Tap crew on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube, and follow along for updates on when the crew reunites next.
Listen to Episode #481
Catch the full conversation with The Guys on Tap Crew on Your Morning Drive, wherever you listen.
